AADAO Wind Down -- Oversight Updates and Reports

All wind-down progress reports and status updates will be posted in this thread. For detailed background on the DAO-termination process and objectives, please review the forum discussion here: https://forum.cosmos.network/t/proposal-draft-terminate-aadao-mandate-and-operations-within-60-days/15701/53.

June 2025 Staffing & Compensation

Role FTE % Monthly Compensation
Grants Reviewer 40% $3,500
Operations Coordinator 40% $2,200
Venture Specialist 40% $3,520
Grants Lead 40% $3,520
Internal Auditor & Accountant (Oversight) 25% $3,520
Elected Member (Oversight) 35% $4,200
Marketing & Communications (Contractor) 9% $435

Reduction: Venture Specialist and Grants Lead roles eliminated effective June 30, 2025.

July 2025 Staffing & Compensation

Role FTE % Monthly Compensation One-Time Additional Compensation
Grants Reviewer 50% $4,375 $2,500
Operations Coordinator 55% $3,025 $2,500
Internal Auditor & Accountant (Oversight) 35% $4,550 —
Elected Member (Oversight) 65% $7,800 —
Marketing & Communications (Contractor) 17% $870 —

Reduction: Grants Reviewer and Marketing & Comms Contractor roles eliminated effective July 31, 2025.

July compensation reflects elevated FTE percentages as core contributors and oversight members worked extended hours to support wind-down objectives communicated here.

One-time $2,500 payments (July 30) to Grants Reviewer (“Joni”) and Operations Coordinator cover transaction-signing availability through Dec 2025 and Grants SubDao wallet management from draw-down transition to grants program closure.

Operations Coordinator Offboarding
The engagement may extend through Aug 31, 2025 due to critical data remediation/recovery/reconciliation work.

Current Portfolio Status

As of 1 Aug 2025

Active Grants (11)

Grant Name Supervision Type Approved Disbursed Remaining Status
Passage: Supercharging ATOM Use-Cases in the Metaverse Standard Oversight $75,000 $40,000 $35,000 Active
Superbolt: Bringing Advanced NFTFi to AEZ Standard Oversight $125,000 $40,000 $85,000 Active
Pryzm: Supercharging Yield Optimization Standard Oversight $50,000 $20,000 $30,000 Active
Quadratic Funding for the AEZ Standard Oversight $200,000 $120,000 $80,000 Active
Huggin: ATOM Community Activation in Istanbul Standard Oversight $16,000 $10,000 $6,000 Active
Votion: Hydro Vote Aggregator Standard Oversight $50,000 $25,000 $25,000 Active
Immunefi: Bug Bounty Program for Hydro Ecosystem Standard Oversight $57,882 $14,471 $43,411 Active
Zephrus: Hydro Vote Aggregator Standard Oversight $85,000 $20,000 $65,000 Active
Token Terminal ICL Primary $200,000 $200,000 $0 Active
Archive Node for Cosmos Hub ICL Primary $12,000 $6,000 $6,000 Active
Zellic (Cosmos Hub audits) ICL Primary $440,000 $308,000 $132,000 Active
TOTALS — $1,310,882 $803,471 $507,411 —

Note

  • Standard Oversight: Milestone-based disbursements supervised by AADAO Oversight with ICL support (as needed).

  • ICL Primary: Supervised by Interchain Labs with AADAO Oversight support (as needed).

Discontinued Grants (2)

Grant Name Approved Disbursed Cancelled Status
Asteroid Protocol $111,000 $76,000 $35,000 Discontinued
Margined Protocol (Delta Neutral Vaults for Hydro) $50,000 $20,000 $30,000 Discontinued
TOTALS $161,000 $96,000 $65,000 —

Note

Cancelled amounts will be added to the unused balance returning to the Cosmos Hub Community Pool. Both grants were terminated during the recent wind-down period.

Active Investments (10)

Of the ten investment agreements, six are publicly disclosed: Elys Network, Union, Convexity Labs (Plaza Finance), Drop, Sphinx, and Shaga.
Four are fully executed but remain confidential under nondisclosure provisions.

Ventures Portfolio – Legal Remediation Required

  • Issue: Investment agreements with Elys Network and Union Labs were executed by contributors lacking signing authority, rendering contracts invalid.

  • Resolution: Agreements are being novated with a valid Trustee signature; investee teams have been notified.


Financial Provisions

Trustee Operational Reserve

  • Restricted Expense Grant (REG): $40,000 USDC to Lemma Ltd (AADAO Trustee)

  • Purpose: Cover third-party legal & administrative expenses through Dec 31, 2028

  • Rationale: With AADAO wallets being deprecated, a pre-authorized reserve of funds is needed to ensure the Trustee can meet episodic legal and administrative costs without operational delays or funding friction.

  • Restriction: Funds may be used only for permitted expenses

  • Return: Unused funds returned to the Cosmos Hub Community Pool within 30 days of trust dissolution or 30 days after Dec 31, 2028

  • Technical Support: ICL will facilitate fund returns as needed

Trustee Approves ICL for “Venture Support”/”Protocol Support” Duties

After the Venture Specialist’s departure, a gap emerged in support services for AADAO investee teams. The Trustee interviewed @Mag, consulted his provided references, and concluded that Mag/ICL is well-qualified to assume this role. The venture-support function is limited in scope: offering ad-hoc technical guidance and facilitating introductions to ecosystem investors.

Trustee Service Extension

  • Term: 2 years (2027–2028)

  • Fee: $6,000 per year ( $12,000 total )


Infrastructure & Data Management Risks

Data Loss

  • Slack: Material messages lost due to deletion or non-renewal/downgrade (administrator and owner of AADAO Slack: Ryan Orr/“Better Future”); root cause unclear. Oversight has repeatedly stated that it does not seek access to or preservation of contributors’ private 1:1 messages. However, substantial discussions and governance records were exchanged in sub-DAO group channels and various ad-hoc formations. All non-1:1 correspondence must therefore be retained.

  • Documentation Gaps: ClickUp insufficiently populated; lacks key information because vital context was created and kept in Slack, much of which has since been lost. Oversight first identified these data gaps in June 2024, yet they remain unaddressed. The resulting inconsistencies are especially problematic for understanding and evaluating investment decisions and activities.

Info Integrity Measures

  • System Renewals (2 years):

    • Google Drive, Dual seat access (Oversight + ICL)

    • ClickUp, Dual seat access (Oversight + ICL)

    • Slack: Renewal status uncertain.

  • Socials

    • Administrative access to the AADAO website, X/Twitter account, and Cosmos Hub Forum account have been shared Oversight and @qxnico (ICL).

      Next month’s report will include a detailed cost breakdown for all essential tooling renewals, with expenses projected to stay below $3,000. I’ve also asked the Internal Auditor & Accountant for updated Financial Statements – will be posted here as soon as they’re made available.

5 Likes

The data loss part makes me furious.

Thanks for the report Grace!

Grants reviewer getting over 4k a month is honestly disgusting. Never responded to their emails as it is. Highly convinced this whole thing was just a slush fund for these guys pals. Easiest 50k/year anyone’s ever received.

2 Likes

We would like to request an update on the expenditure breakdown for August and September @Cosmos_Nanny .

It is important to note that the DAO was expected to be closed well before this point. The repeated extensions are beginning to feel like an unnecessary drag, and it may soon fall upon the community to take a definitive stance to bring this process to a conclusion.

2 Likes

First, my apologies for the delayed response. I’ll share a full expenditure update tomorrow.

At present, there are no active core contributor members.

The only individuals receiving remuneration are myself and Matt Brown (Financial Controller & Auditor) – and our compensation varies from 25% - 50% FTE since end of July.

Delisse Gamboa, the Operations Associate, and @CuriousJ were compensated through mid-August and received a one-time payment of 2,500 USDC each to ensure continued availability for proposal reviews and signing activities on DAODAO through December 2025. (Oversight members can’t simultaneously create and authorize payments.) At this juncture, I’m directly reviewing grantee milestone deliverables, and when satisfied, payment proposals are created by me, and subsequently approved by Delisse and Joni.

Some good news: the grants portion of the program may be fully concluded by the end of this month (rather than Dec). In addition to standard administrative and closure activities, two substantive matters remain:

  1. Return of Assets: The 450,000 ATOM liquidity position on Astroport/Stride (via Proposal 800) must be returned to the Cosmos Hub (more details on where we are with this process tomorrow)

  2. Governance and Legal Structure: There are material deficiencies in AADAO’s Guernsey Trust Deed. It’s super important that the establishment docs and gov framework reflect prudent, responsible, and community-aligned promises. Specifically, the shared understanding that upon completion of all DAO activities (grantmaking and ventures), ALL remaining assets will revert to the Cosmos Hub cp.

Cosmos Labs generously connected me with the ICF legal team to assist with this review. Pending their legal analysis, I’ll provide a detailed update on the governance remediation plan for Atom Accelerator Trust shortly.

5 Likes

Thank you for your response. We look forward to a swift resolution of the “Return of Assets”, which we anticipate will mark the final milestone before the trust’s termination. This step should effectively close what we can now consider a failed experiment. It is time to move forward.

FYI – the Trust cannot be terminated until all investment agreements reach maturity (projected end date: December 2028). Lemma LTD will remain the BVI Trustee, and allocated $40,000 grant to cover incidental administrative and legal costs for the next 2+ years. Any unsed funds from this grant will return to the community pool at end of Trust’s term. The Trustee is to provide expense reports directly to Cosmos Labs’ @Mag

Any balance that remains from Proposals 95 and 865 will return to the pool with closure of all grant activites – am aiming to close out all active grants by the end of this month (pending grantees’ responsiveness and cooperation).

FYI

1 Like

Community Update:

Clarifying AADAO “Sunset” (again), Funds Return Process, & Current Financials.

Several community members have asked why AADAO funds were not immediately returned to the Cosmos Hub cp following AADAO’s “sunset” announcement last year. It’s a fair question, and stems from a persistent misunderstanding triggered by the day AADAO used the word “sunset” a year ago.

I’ve addressed this multiple times across multiple channels. I sincerely hope this is the last time I have to do this.
Inshallah.

What “Sunset” Actually Meant

When AADAO core contributors announced a “sunset”, they were not dissolving the DAO or ending operations.

In reality, the only thing that was being retired was the core team’s collective will to seek renewal funding from the Hub.

Unfortunately, the term “sunset” implied a full and imminent shutdown, but that’s not what happened.

In practice, AADAO remained operational after the “sunset” announcement. Between October and December 2024, the DAO approved $1.9 million in new grants, including roughly $588,000 in venture-related funding.


For more on these late-term approvals and allocations, read the Ninth Transparency Report.

Many of these grants include milestone payments extending into late 2025, meaning the DAO both retained and CREATED new financial and operational obligations that made an immediate drawdown of operations or the return of funds impossible.

Funds cannot be returned while active contracts, milestones, or administrative commitments are outstanding.

AADAO Funding Summary & SubDAO Wallet Activity

The DAO received 1,563,811 ATOM in total from the Cosmos Hub through:

All of the above funds were originally sent to AADAO’s 4-of-7 multisig:
cosmos1jggracsvp6fkw0ktf544lpda6dwrrxggx9a20n

From there, they were distributed across three DAODAO subDAO wallets:

Most of the ATOM distributed through Cosmos Hub Proposals 96 and 865 was allocated to the StratComm subDAO wallet, which has since been fully closed out at my suggestion.
“Closed out” means the subDAO wallet has been deprecated, and all remaining unused tokens have been returned in full to the cp.

  • StratComm Wallet: Returned 216,310 ATOM and 80,591 USDC to the cp in July 2025 via Proposal A41.

  • Operations Wallet: Monthly compensation payments are approved and released from this subDAO wallet. The final core contributors on payroll were @CuriousJ and Delisse Gamboa (Operations Associate), whose last salary disbursement occurred in July 2025.

    Currently, the only individuals receiving monthly compensation (ranging between 20% - 65% FTE) are the two active Oversight Committee members, myself and Matt Brown (@mattatom). We are compensated at a rate of $75/hr.

  • Grants Wallet: Initial, milestone-based, and final grant payments are made from this subDAO wallet. Historically, this wallet was also used to disburse venture-related outlays.

    To date, Operations and Grants hold approximately $1 million combined; the unused balance of these funds will be returned once all outstanding grant and administrative obligations are closed or fulfilled. As of the end of July, 11 grants remained active. Since then, I have either discontinued or accelerated the closure of 8 of 11 grants.

I’m aiming to close out all grants program commitments by mid-November, and the funds remaining in Ops and Grants subDAO wallets can return to the cp in the same manner the StratComm funds returned to the Hub.

The 450,000 ATOM POL that AADAO stewards as per Proposal 800 requires the cooperation and coordination of the 4-7 msig. Once the tokens finish unbonding (the unwind is occurring in four tranches due to rate limits), the final step must be performed by the msig. Cosmos Labs is providing technical support to ensure the ATOM is returned responsibly and safely.

Top Level Multisig

The 4-of-7 multisig signers are:

Youssef Amrani

Ryan Orr (Better Future)

Reena Shtedle (Citadel)

Luke Saunders (Delphi)

Xavier Meegan

Jeonghwan, Cosmostation

Dilan A. (Imperator)

  • Cosmostation and Imperator remain consistently and exceedingly responsive for all signing-related issues. Thank you :purple_heart:

  • Ryan Orr is non-responsive.

  • Youssef Amrani, though formally removed from the DAO, remains on the msig and will not be contacted.

Administrative and Trust Wind-Down

To ensure that the AADAO Guernsey Trust is properly administered and governed independently of current Oversight members, and to guarantee that the Trust is wound down in compliance with its obligations while all records are securely preserved:

Karel Olivier is the Lemma interface for all AADAO Trustee matters.

These minimal workspaces remain active so that the Trustee retains access to historical data in case of dispute.

Any unused funds from this restricted expense grant will also be returned to the cp at termination of the Trust.

Transparency and Accountability

All financial transactions, subDAO proposals, and administrative actions have been communicated transparently through AADAO’s and Oversight’s public channels: forum, Twitter, and on-chain subDAO proposal text.

Unlike earlier subDAO proposals, recent spend props (since August 1) now include sufficient context and documentation so that any community member, regardless of prior familiarity with AADAO’s history or operations, can understand the purpose and justification for each disbursement.

Should you have any additional questions regarding the financials or the financial status of the DAO, please tag Matt Brown (AADAO Oversight, Accountant & Auditor) @mattatom.

Finally, if you have questions for me, please post them here on the Forum and within this thread. I’d prefer to avoid discussions on X, as conversations there become fragmented and difficult to track. Maintaining a single, coherent, and transparent source of shared information will help ensure clarity and accountability for everyone involved.

Thank you.

2 Likes

Hey everyone! :waving_hand: Reading through the detailed update on AADAO’s “sunset,” I’ve put together a quick summary to help clarify things. Hope this helps! :rocket:

• “Sunset” Misconception :sunset:: When AADAO announced its “sunset” last year, it wasn’t an immediate shutdown. Operations continued, and they even approved $1.9 million in new grants with payments extending into late 2025. This wasn’t a full and instant halt.
• Fund Return Delays :money_with_wings:: Funds couldn’t be returned immediately due to active contracts, pending milestones, and ongoing administrative commitments. These obligations needed to be honored.
• AADAO Funding Overview :glowing_star:: AADAO received a total of 1,563,811 ATOM from the Cosmos Hub through Proposals 95 and 865. They also manage a 450,000 ATOM POL deployment from Proposal 800.
• SubDAO Wallet Activity :briefcase::
* StratComm Wallet: This wallet has been officially closed, and 216,310 ATOM and 80,591 USDC were returned to the cp in July 2025. :white_check_mark:
* Operations & Grants Wallets: These currently hold ~$1 million combined. The remaining balance will be returned once all outstanding grant and administrative obligations are completed. 11 grants were active in July; 8 have since been discontinued or fast-tracked for closure. The goal is to wrap up all grant commitments by mid-November. :hourglass_not_done:
• ATOM POL Return :shield:: The 450,000 ATOM POL requires the cooperation of the 4-of-7 multisig for its return, with the unbonding process happening in four tranches.
• Multisig Status :handshake:: The multisig signers are listed, with some being highly responsive (Cosmostation, Imperator) and others less so (Ryan Orr, Youssef Amrani).
• Administrative Wind-Down :scroll:: Funds have been allocated to ensure the proper management and winding down of the AADAO Guernsey Trust, including securing services from Lemma until 2028 and covering necessary operational costs.
• Transparency & Accountability :eye:: All financial transactions and subDAO actions have been communicated transparently. The request is to keep further questions within the forum thread for clarity and accountability.

In essence, AADAO’s wind-down is a complex process due to existing financial and administrative commitments, with a clear goal to return all remaining funds to the Cosmos Hub once these obligations are met.

Hope this simplifies the information for everyone! :folded_hands:

Thank you for the update Grace! Much appreciated

1 Like

Thank you, @Cosmos_Nanny for the updates and your efforts to ensure clarity and transparency. However, we have some concerns:

  1. Is there a document or archive where we can view reports of the grants that have been approved so far? Specifically, we are interested in understanding why these grants were approved and how the funded projects have been utilized. If such information exists, please direct us to it.

  2. We would like to understand what it would take to have something like an “AADAO Sunrise.” We propose creating a “Sunrise Council” responsible for restructuring the DAO in all areas, making it more organized and prepared for a V2 sunrise by Q2 of 2026.

@Cosmos_Nanny Please we still await your response